Is he a Cylon? *Season 3 Spoilers*

[Kosh Naranek]

Well, its a possibility. We know there are a group of human-form Cylons we've not seen yet and the question is also brought up on screen. So, do you think its possible that Gaius Baltar is one of them?

[Majestic]

Please add spoliers, as only US people have seen season 3 and it would spoil it for non-US viewers.

[Jasoneagle]

If you think about it, it is only too convienent that he see's Six in his mind and that he knew how to detect a Cylon in season one and noone ever saw a Skin Job before. After all did we ever see the results of his test on himself?? If he ever did one.

[Kosh Naranek]

@Majestic: Oops, sorry about that. But, TBH, don't you think its fair as you have seen farther ahead in Doctor Who than we have?

@Jasoneagle: Agreed. Just too many coincidences.

[Majestic]

@Majestic: Oops, sorry about that. But, TBH, don't you think its fair as you have seen farther ahead in Doctor Who than we have?


Just remember in the future to add them.

And as far as Doctor Who is concerned, you might understand how us Australians and people from other countries have felt when coming on the net a someone (usually a US resident due to getting the latest episodes) mentions something they saw in the lastest season of a show that the rest of us may not see for 12 to 18 months.

[EAS_Intrepid]

If you think about it, it is only too convienent that he see's Six in his mind and that he knew how to detect a Cylon in season one and noone ever saw a Skin Job before. After all did we ever see the results of his test on himself?? If he ever did one.

Ever thought of the possibility that the test was a *fake*?

[Syf]

I've been keeping up with BSG. I do not think Batlar is a Cylon. But If he is, we should find out by the end of S3.

[Jasoneagle]

Ever thought of the possibility that the test was a *fake*?
Then why did it Detect Sharon as a Cylon?

[Majestic]

If you think about it, it is only too convienent that he see's Six in his mind and that he knew how to detect a Cylon in season one and noone ever saw a Skin Job before. After all did we ever see the results of his test on himself?? If he ever did one.

Human form Cylons (Skin Jobs) were seen in the mini series, so that statement is wrong.

[EAS_Intrepid]

Then why did it Detect Sharon as a Cylon?

Good point. 1 for you!

[Jasoneagle]

Human form Cylons (Skin Jobs) were seen in the mini series, so that statement is wrong.
I was talking from the perspective of the show, up intill they where put into the miniseries noone had seen one, but they only saw I think 3 of them by the end of the Miniseries.

[Kosh Naranek]

@Majestic: Sorry about being snippy like that.

@All: I agree. I don't remember anything about Baltar testing himself. Then there's also the whole thing about him doing that thing that's so similar to what the Cylons call "Projecting'.

[Jasoneagle]

@Majestic: Sorry about being snippy like that.

@All: I agree. I don't remember anything about Baltar testing himself. Then there's also the whole thing about him doing that thing that's so similar to what the Cylons call "Projecting'.
Not to sound like I am posting against what I said but the Projecting is infact Daydreaming.

[Majestic]

Its hard to tell, there are so many hints saying that he may be a Cylon, but other things tip me off saying that he may not.

I guess only time will tell and currently their aren't enough facts either way to give us viewers enough proof to make a conclusion.